Mike is granted his hearing but his chances of success are blocked when Anita Gibbs, the U.S. Attorney who prosecuted him, is appointed as a member of the Character and Fitness Committee of the New York State Bar, reminding Mike and Harvey that the vote has to be unanimous and that she would never say yes.
In an attempt to change her mind, Harvey presents her with the Liberty Rail files, telling her that he is giving it to her with no strings attached to prove that he is a changed man, hoping that it would make her realize that Mike changed as well. However, she tells Harvey that she will vote yes for Mike if he gets Mike to admit that Harvey hired him despite being a fraud, thus getting Harvey disbarred in the process. Although Harvey attempts to take the deal, Mike makes Harvey realize that Gibbs wants both of them and thus would never honor the deal anyhow.
Anita Gibbs asks Mike on the stand if anyone at Pearson Specter Litt knew he was a fraud while he worked there, reminding Mike that he has to be truthful since he has openly stated to be a changed and truthful person. Before Mike can answer, Jessica Pearson strolls in and admits that she knew he was a fraud. She then tells the committee that years ago, a woman who had chronic back pain stole prescription pads from the hospital she worked at in order to get drugs, an offense that is worth seven years in prison. However, the attorney handling the case, Anita Gibbs herself, showed compassion and offered probation instead while also sealing the records. Jessica tells Anita that the woman is now an E.R. doctor saving lives and is changing the world because of what Gibbs did for her, and how she could do the same for Mike.
That night at the firm, Jessica tells everyone that the woman in the story is really a man, who was Walter Samson's godson, and that Gibbs blackmailed Samson in order to be placed on the committee. While Harvey decides to strong-arm Gibbs before the vote is announced, Jessica tells Harvey not to, using an example of Aesop's fable - since Gibbs knows it was really a man and she knows Jessica knows it as well, she would realize that Jessica is attempting to rekindle her compassion without divulging the true story. Despite Jessica most likely facing disbarment, she reminds them that she now lives in Chicago and thus is not affected by it. Before Harvey and Louis can react to her tactic, Harvey gets a phone call from Craig Seidel, and announces that Mike is officially a member of the New York State Bar.
Mike turns down Harvey's offer to return to the firm and after being confronted by Oliver for being a shady lawyer, approaches Nathan and tells him the truth. Nathan fires him but Oliver sticks up for Mike, reminding Nathan that while Mike is shady, he cares about people and has done a lot of good for the firm, having beat a giant like Velocity Data. Nathan then agrees to keep Mike on payroll provided that Mike continues to earn $50,000 for the firm.
Harvey, however, convinces Mike to return to the firm with a cheque, telling him to donate half of it to the legal clinic to fund them for a whole year. Mike tells Harvey to double it since he wants to fund it for two years, and stipulates that he would only return so long as he is allowed to bring the clinic on any case he wants, he is allowed to bring anyone from the clinic to the firm without Harvey or Louis' permission, and that the Harvard rule is tossed out the window. Harvey agrees, and so Mike asks for one more thing - Harvey's office. While Harvey initially refuses, Mike tells Harvey that it is time for Harvey to take the reins and take Jessica's office, and Harvey agrees.
Tara decides that Louis is not the kind of man she wants to spend the rest of her life with and breaks up with him, leaving him devastated.
After Donna realizes that "The Donna" has an overlap with another company and that she cannot take the product worldwide, she enlists Louis for help. However, Louis is only able to get her a deal. Not wanting the money, Donna asks Harvey for help, but Harvey tells her to take the money. Donna then tearfully admits that she does not want money but instead something more in life, and that she is still figuring out what it is.